Duplicate Baldrige Core Values
Visionary Leadership and Focus on the Future
It is highly doubtful that the Baldrige Program intended to describe two Core Values which are as highly redundant as the 'Visionary Leadership' and 'Focus on the Future'. However, it appears that is what has happened as evidenced by the comparison below.
Core Values
Comparison
Visionary
Leadership
versus
Focus on the Future
|
Visionary
Leadership
[16] |
Focus on the
Future |
|
Your organization’s
senior
leaders [6] should set
directions
[8]
and create a
customer focus [2], clear and visible
values,
and high expectations. The
directions
[8],
values, and expectations should balance the needs of all your
stakeholders
[4], [5], [9], [10], [11], [14]. Your
leaders [6]
should ensure the creation of
strategies
[8],
systems, and methods for achieving
performance
[15] excellence,
stimulating
innovation [3], building
knowledge
and capabilities,
and ensuring organizational
sustainability [1]. The defined
values
and
strategies [8] should help guide all of your organization’s
activities and decisions.
Senior
leaders [6] should inspire and encourage your entire
workforce
[5]
to contribute, to develop and
learn, to
be
innovative [3], and to embrace
change [13].
Senior
leaders [6] should be responsible to your organization’s
governance
body for their actions and
performance
[15]. The
governance body should be responsible ultimately to all your
stakeholders
[4], [5], [9], [10], [11], [14], for the
ethics,
actions, and
performance [15] of your organization and its
senior
leaders [6].
Senior
leaders [6] should serve as
role models
through their
ethical behavior and their personal involvement in
planning
[8],
communicating, coaching the
workforce
[5],
developing
future leaders
[7],
reviewing
organizational
performance
[15], and recognizing
members of
your workforce
[5].
As role models,
they can reinforce
ethics,
values,
and expectations while building leadership,
commitment
[12], and initiative throughout your organization. |
Creating a
sustainable
[1] organization requires understanding the
short- and
longer-term factors [8] that affect your organization and
marketplace
[2]. The pursuit of
sustainable
growth [1] and
sustained
[1] performance [15]
leadership [16]
requires a strong future orientation and a willingness to
make long-term
commitments
[12] to key
stakeholders
[4], [5],
[9], [10], [11],
[14]—your
customers
[2],
workforce
[5],
suppliers
[9], partners
[10],
and
stockholders
[11];
the public
[14];
and your
community
[4]. Your organization’s
planning
[8]
should anticipate many factors, such as
customers’
expectations
[2],
new business
and
partnering
[10]
opportunities,
workforce
development
[5]
and hiring
needs
[5], the increasingly global
marketplace
[2],
technological
developments,
changes [13]
in customer
and market segments
[2],
new business
models, evolving
regulatory
requirements, changes in
community
and societal expectations
and needs [4], and
strategic
moves
[8] by
competitors.
Strategic
objectives [8] and
resource
allocations need to accommodate these influences. A focus on
the future includes
developing
your leaders
[7],
workforce
[5],
and
suppliers [9]; accomplishing
effective
succession planning
[7];
creating
opportunities for innovation
[3];
and anticipating
societal
responsibilities and concerns
[4]. |
|
Unmatched terms:
Values, systems,
learn, ethics, governance, communication, role models |
Unmatched terms:
Regulatory
requirements, technological developments, competitors, new business
and new business models |
History:
"Visionary Leadership" was first introduced in 1991 as "Leadership". It was renamed to "Visionary Leadership" in 2000. The word "visionary" is part of the issue contributing to the confusion related to a future focus.
"Focus on the Future" was first introduced in 1992 as "Long-Range Outlook". It was renamed "Long-Range View of the Future" in 1995 and later changed to "Focus on the Future" in 2000.
Conclusions:
·
Many to most terms appear to overlap (terms that
appear to overlap are
highlighted in yellow and numerically mapped)
·
Several terms do not appear to overlap (these
unmatched terms that do not appear to overlap are
highlighted in green)
·
Many of the terms that do not overlap should
apparently be considered for inclusion in the other Core Value, For example,
values, systems, learning, ethics, governance, and communication would appear to
fit well into the Focus on the Future core value. Conversely, regulatory
requirements, technological developments, competitors, new business, and new
business models would appear to fit well into the Visionary Leadership core
value.
Observation: It does not appear that Baldrige ever intended for 'Visionary Leadership' and 'Focus on the Future' to be as highly redundant as they are. However, they obviously overlap significantly and the reason may be the same reason that is causing problems for users of the Criteria. the Scoring Guidelines, the other Core Values - bloating or too many words. If these are actually different Core Values, they need to be reworded to more concisely and effectively clarify to Criteria users how they are different and what their core focus is. Until then . . .
Recommendation:
Synthesize the Visionary Leadership
and Focus on the Future Core Values
into a single Core Value for 2012.
Baldrige Core Values Navigator
Thank you for using the only truly integrated version of the Baldrige Core Values available anywhere. Paul Steel
Baldrige Improvement Tools and Resources . . . from the most experienced source
(See more resources at: Baldrige Excellence Tools and Resources Home)
|
Essentials: |
||||||||||||
|
Tools: |
OrgProfiler | |||||||||||
|
Core Competencies: |
||||||||||||
|
Special Focus: |
|
|